Not all trees handle Pennsylvania's storms equally. Lancaster County's mix of nor'easters, summer thunderstorms, and ice events exposes structural weaknesses in specific species that homeowners should know about before the next storm season.
Bradford pears are the most commonly reported storm-failure tree throughout Lancaster County. Planted extensively in the county's residential developments from the 1980s through the early 2000s, these trees have a fundamental structural flaw: their branches grow at tight, narrow angles from the trunk, trapping bark at each union and preventing solid wood-to-wood connection.
Under ice load or high wind, these unions split catastrophically. A Bradford pear doesn't lose a branch during a storm — it splits in half at the trunk. The neighborhoods along Route 30 through Mountville and Columbia, the newer developments in southern Lancaster County, and suburban streets through Ephrata and Lititz regularly see Bradford pear failures during ice events and summer thunderstorms.
Pennsylvania has recognized the problem: Bradford pear is now considered invasive and the state has encouraged replacement with native species. Trees that are 20–30 years old and showing any trunk splitting or included bark should be assessed promptly.
Silver maples were the street tree of choice throughout Lancaster County's post-war suburbs. They grow fast, provide quick shade, and are easy to establish. They're also notorious for brittle wood that snaps rather than bends under storm loading.
The silver maples planted along residential streets in Manheim Township in the 1960s and 1970s are now 50–60 foot trees with large, heavy limbs growing over roads, roofs, and power lines. Their shallow root systems are also prone to uprooting in saturated soil during heavy summer rain events — a tree that looks completely healthy can uproot in one storm after prolonged wet conditions.
Silver maple limbs regularly snap in Lancaster County's nor'easters, ice storms, and summer thunderstorms. Trees within limb-fall distance of a structure should be assessed for pruning or removal.
Hackberry is a native Pennsylvania tree that grows throughout Lancaster County, particularly along fence rows, woodland edges, and in older residential areas. While generally considered a resilient tree, hackberry frequently develops included bark at branch unions — similar to Bradford pear but less severe — and is classified as susceptible to storm and ice damage by forestry research. Hackberry near structures should be assessed for branch union strength.
Willows are shallow-rooted, fast-growing trees with long, pendulous branches that offer high wind resistance but low structural strength. Their narrow branch angles and flexible but brittle outer wood make them prone to limb failure in wind. Willows near the many Lancaster County waterways — the Conestoga River, Pequea Creek, and the numerous streams through Manheim Township and Lititz — are particularly at risk of uprooting in saturated soil conditions after heavy rain.
Green ash trees throughout Lancaster County that have been weakened or killed by emerald ash borer are significant storm hazards. Dead and dying ash trees become brittle rapidly, and their structural failure in storms is unpredictable. An ash tree that was alive and healthy three years ago may now be a dead standing tree with significantly compromised wood strength. EAB-affected ash trees near structures should be assessed and removed promptly.
For comparison, trees that generally perform well in Lancaster County storms include white oak (strong U-shaped branch structure), black walnut (coarse branching, strong wood), red maple (more flexible than silver maple), hickory, and Eastern red cedar. If you're replacing a storm-damaged tree, these species offer significantly better storm performance than silver maple or Bradford pear.
Lancaster County's storm calendar creates two distinct types of tree stress, and understanding the difference helps explain why certain trees fail when they do.
Ice adds static weight that stresses every branch union simultaneously. A quarter inch of ice on branches is enough to snap smaller limbs; a half inch brings down larger limbs and causes trunk splits. Bradford pears are uniquely vulnerable to ice because their included-bark branch unions act as pre-formed failure points. During a significant ice event, Bradford pears in Lancaster County don't slowly weaken — they split suddenly and completely. The trees along Route 722 through Elizabethtown and the older subdivisions around Ephrata see significant Bradford pear failures during ice events most winters.
Summer storms bring wind and rain simultaneously. The combination of full leaf canopy (creating maximum wind resistance) and saturated soil from preceding rain creates ideal conditions for uprooting shallow-rooted trees. Silver maples, willows, and Bradford pears in saturated Lancaster County soils uproot most frequently during late-summer convective storms when the ground has been softened by weeks of summer rain. Manheim Township's clay soils hold moisture particularly well, amplifying this risk.
Nor'easters deliver heavy wet snow and wind over extended periods. Trees in early or late leaf — before full winter hardening or during spring emergence — are most vulnerable. The weight of wet snow on a full or partially leafed canopy can exceed what ice accumulation creates, and the extended duration of nor'easter events (12–36 hours) creates cumulative stress that sudden thunderstorms don't. Large silver maples and poorly structured oaks in exposed locations throughout Lancaster County fail regularly during significant nor'easter events.
Call or fill out the form — local professionals respond promptly during business hours.
(717) 716-6715